Paid leads get you customers fast, and for plenty of contractors they pay for themselves. The catch is that you rent every one of them: the fee is gone whether you win the job or not, and when you stop paying, the requests stop too. A Google profile with strong reviews works the other way. It builds slowly and keeps working when you stop spending.
This guide helps you judge lead sites on their numbers, shows what to track, and lays out how to build a source of work you own. You do not have to drop Angi or Thumbtack. The point is that they should not be your only source.
Jump to:
- How lead sites charge
- What lead sites do well
- The number to track: cost per job won
- What you rent and what you own
- Who paid leads suit, and who they do not
- How to reduce your dependence on lead sites
- The posts in this guide
How lead sites charge
Lead platforms sell you access to a customer's request. The details differ, and they change, so read the current terms before you sign anything. Here is what the platforms say themselves.
Thumbtack. Thumbtack charges pros when they get leads or contact customers, and the price depends on the job type and location. Check the current pricing in your pro account before you commit. Our full breakdown is in what Thumbtack charges for leads.
Angi. Angi's pro sign-up page says there were "over 1.5M opportunities on Angi last month" and invites you to get started. It shows no prices, and it gives a phone number for questions. The pro help pages (still on the HomeAdvisor domain, branded Angi Leads) say you pay "a nominal fee for each lead you match to" and that different sized jobs have different lead fees. They give no amounts, and they say customers are connected with "multiple Angi Leads service professionals," so one request can reach several contractors. They also say the company makes no guarantee of work volume. Ask for the price and the contract terms in writing. More in is Angi worth it for contractors.
HomeAdvisor. The pro help pages that carry the HomeAdvisor name now describe the Angi Leads service. If you are comparing the two, ask the sales rep what is actually on offer today. See HomeAdvisor for contractors.
Nextdoor. Different model. Nextdoor says a Business Page is free, with unlimited free posts, neighbor recommendations and replies to messages. It also sells ads through Ads Manager and does not publish ad prices on the page we checked. See Nextdoor for business.
If a price is not public, treat it as unknown. Do not rely on a number you read in a forum, because lead prices vary by trade, zip code and season, and a figure from someone else's account may not be yours.
Warning: Before you pay for any lead service
Ask for these in writing: the price per lead or per month, the contract length, how renewal and cancellation work, whether leads are shared with other contractors, and what happens when a lead turns out to be bad (a credit, a refund or nothing).
What lead sites do well
Lead sites have real strengths.
- Speed. Requests can start arriving soon after you sign up. A Google profile with no reviews cannot do that.
- Intent. The person filled in a form asking for a pro. That is a warmer start than a stranger scrolling Facebook.
- No marketing skill needed. You answer requests and quote. You do not have to write posts or ask for reviews.
- Fills gaps. A slow month, a new crew you need to keep busy, a new service area. Paid leads can plug that.
- Some trades and areas do well. Plenty of contractors report that certain job types in certain zip codes work for them. Your own numbers will tell you if you are one of them.
The weaknesses are on the cost side. You pay when you do not win. Some leads are shared with other contractors, so you are quoting against others on the same request. A review left on the platform does not carry over to your Google profile. And the price can move without you changing anything.
The number to track: cost per job won
Do not judge a lead site on the price of one lead. Judge it on what it costs to win a job.
Cost per job won = total lead spend in a month / jobs won from those leads
Here is a worked example. The business is made up and the figures are illustrative, not typical results.
Dale's HVAC buys leads for two months. Dale and all the figures here are made up.
Month 1 | Month 2 | |
|---|---|---|
Leads bought | 20 | 24 |
Total lead spend | $400 | $480 |
Jobs won | 4 | 3 |
Cost per job won | $100 | $160 |
Month 2 cost more per job even though Dale bought more leads. Without the table, he would have seen a busy phone and a bigger bill and not much else.
Now put it next to profit. If a typical job nets Dale $900 before lead fees, a $100 fee is a small slice and a $160 fee is still fine. If a typical job nets $250, $160 takes most of it. The same fee can be fine or painful depending on the job, which is why you need your own figures.
Two more things worth tracking alongside it:
- Win rate. Jobs won divided by leads bought. Dale's was 4 in 20 in month 1 and 3 in 24 in month 2.
- Time per lead. Calling back, driving out and writing quotes all cost hours. If you quote ten leads to win one, count the evenings.
A small spreadsheet is enough. One row per lead: date, source, job type, quoted, won, price paid, job value. After 60 to 90 days you will know whether the site is working for you.
What you rent and what you own
Lead sites and your own reputation both bring in customers, but they do different things after you stop.
| Compared | Paid leads | Your own reputation |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Per lead or by membership, depending on the platform. Check current terms. | Your time, or a tool that saves it. No per-inquiry fee. |
| Speed | Fast. Requests can start arriving soon after signup. | Slow. Reviews and posts add up over months. |
| If you stop | The requests stop. | Your reviews and profile stay, and keep working. |
| Competition | Often several contractors quoting the same request. | Customers who searched for you or were told your name. Often a smaller field. |
| Reviews | Kept on the platform's own profile. | On your Google profile, which shows in Maps and search. |
The last row matters more than it looks. A customer who got your name from a neighbor will usually look you up on Google before they call. A platform profile may not appear there. A Google profile with a few dozen recent reviews will.
Who paid leads suit, and who they do not
Paid leads tend to suit you if:
- You are new, or your diary is empty this month, and you need calls now.
- You can reply fast. Speed to reply is a big part of winning on these sites.
- You quote well and win a fair share of what you quote.
- Your job values are high enough that a lead fee is a small part of the profit.
- You work in a trade and area where the platform sends a steady flow.
Paid leads tend to disappoint if:
- Your margins are thin and a few lost leads wipe out the profit from a won one.
- You sell on quality, and some leads will be price comparisons.
- You are already busy on referrals and repeat customers and do not need the volume.
- You cannot answer within the hour, because someone else will.
- You have no way of knowing which jobs came from where.
Most contractors sit between the two lists. That is the argument for a mix.
How to reduce your dependence on lead sites
You do not have to quit anything. The aim is to have a second and third source of work so that no single bill, price change or policy change decides your month.
Start tracking where every job comes from
Add one question to every first call: "How did you find us?" Write the answer down. After 60 days you will know your real split between leads, referrals, Google and repeat customers.
Fix your Google Business Profile
Claim it, choose the right primary category, list your services and service area, add real photos. It is free, and it is where a referral checks you out. Our [Google Business Profile optimization checklist](/us/blog/google-business-profile-optimization-checklist) walks through it.
Ask every finished customer for a Google review
Ask while the job is fresh, and make it a single tap with a direct link. The [review link generator](/us/tools/review-link-generator) is free and needs no sign-up. Reviews on Google are the part of your reputation you keep.
Post finished jobs
One photo and two sentences per job on Facebook and Instagram. Neighbors share local work, and it gives people proof before they call. It costs you minutes per job, or nothing once it is automated.
Set up a free Nextdoor business page
It costs nothing, and the people who see it are in your service area. Do not expect volume from it. Treat it as another place where a neighbor's recommendation can land.
Review the numbers every quarter
Compare cost per job won on the lead sites with the jobs coming direct. If direct inquiries are holding steady, trim the lead budget gradually. Check your contract's notice and renewal terms first so you are not caught by an auto-renewal.
For a trade-specific version, see how to get HVAC leads without buying them. The same steps apply to roofing, plumbing and electrical work.
How long does the shift take?
It depends on where you start. A profile with no reviews will take months to build the volume that a lead site gives you in a week. A profile with a decent base of customers and no reviews can improve quickly, because the customers already exist and just have not been asked. Do not cut leads until your own numbers show you can.
The hidden cost on both sides
Lead sites have a visible cost, the fee. The hidden cost is your reply time and the quotes that go nowhere.
Doing your own marketing has a visible cost of nothing and a hidden cost of evenings. Writing posts, chasing reviews and answering them takes real hours, and it is the first thing to slide when you are busy. That is the reason most contractors start strong and stop within a month. We compare it in Mitch vs doing your own marketing.
If you want a sense of what agencies charge for the same work, see how much a marketing agency costs a trades business. And if you are setting a budget, how much a trades business should spend on marketing helps frame it.
A quarterly check you can do in an hour
Once a quarter, sit down with your job list and answer five questions.
- How many jobs came from each source: lead sites, Google, referrals, repeat customers, Nextdoor, Facebook?
- What did each source cost in money and in hours?
- Which source brought the best jobs, meaning the highest profit and the easiest customers?
- Is the direct side (Google, referrals, repeat) growing, flat or shrinking?
- If the biggest source vanished next month, how many weeks could you keep the crew busy?
The fifth question is the one that matters. A business that would be in trouble in three weeks if one platform changed its prices is exposed, however well that platform is doing today. A business with four steady sources can ride out a bad month on any one of them.
Using both
The most practical setup for a lot of contractors is to keep a lead source running and build their own reputation alongside it.
Every job from a lead is also a job you can photograph, post and ask a review for. A customer who found you on Angi can still leave you a Google review, and that review then works for you with the next customer who looks you up. The lead paid for the first job. The review pays for later ones.
Review requests by text need the customer's mobile number and their consent, so ask first. This is general information, not legal advice.
Plan: Where Mitch fits
Mitch does not sell leads. You send in a finished job and it drafts the Facebook and Instagram post, and on the Local plan it also sends a Google review request 24 to 72 hours later and drafts a reply to each review. Nothing posts until you approve it. Social is $99 a month, Local is $189 and Complete is $449. Month to month, with a 14-day free trial and no card. See the [comparison with paying for leads](/us/compare/paying-for-leads) or the [pricing page](/us/pricing).
The posts in this guide
Each of these goes deeper on one platform or question.
- Is Angi worth it for contractors?
- What Thumbtack charges for leads, and is it worth it?
- HomeAdvisor for contractors: what pros say
- Nextdoor for business: is it worth setting up?
- How to get HVAC leads without buying them
- How much does a marketing agency cost a trades business?
- How much should a trades business spend on marketing?
- Mitch vs doing your own marketing
More in the leads and costs hub.
Build the part you keep
14 days free, no card. Send in one finished job and see the posts Mitch writes from it.
Sources
Checked October 9, 2026. Platform terms change, so confirm current details with the platform before you commit.