Thumbtack charges contractors for leads, and the price is not one number. It depends on the job type and your location. Whether it is worth it depends on how many leads turn into jobs and how much those jobs earn you.
This post covers what we can say about Thumbtack's billing, who it tends to suit and how to test it. It is part of our guide to paying for leads vs owning your reputation.
How Thumbtack charges
Thumbtack charges pros when they get leads or contact customers; the price depends on the job type and location. Check the current pricing in your pro account before you commit.
We could not read Thumbtack's help pages or pro pages when we checked, so we are not quoting amounts, billing rules or contract terms. Figures from forums and agency blogs vary a great deal, and none of them can tell you what you will be charged. The prices shown in your own account are the ones that apply to you.
What Thumbtack can do for you
- Customers state what they want. They fill in details about the job, which helps you decide whether to quote.
- Another source of requests. It can help fill a quiet month, depending on your trade and area.
- A way to test the market. You can see what demand looks like for your services before spending on anything else.
Where it can cost you
- You pay for leads you do not win. A fee for a lead or a contact is gone whether or not the job comes through.
- Competition. Customers may hear from several pros, so a quick reply tends to matter.
- Your Thumbtack reviews are separate from Google. They sit on Thumbtack's profile and not on your Google profile.
Who it tends to suit
Thumbtack tends to work for a contractor who can respond within minutes, quotes well and does jobs with profit high enough to absorb the fees.
It tends to disappoint someone with thin margins, or someone who cannot reply fast and sees many requests go nowhere.
How to work out whether it is worth it
Use cost per job won, not cost per lead.
Cost per job won = total Thumbtack spend in a month / jobs won from Thumbtack
An example with made-up figures. Marcus's Painting is an invented business. It spends $350 in a month and wins 5 jobs. Cost per job won is $70. If the average job nets $800, that looks healthy. Next month Marcus spends $500 and wins 3. Cost per job won is about $167. A monthly table shows which way it is heading.
Track these for 60 to 90 days:
- Leads you paid for.
- How many you reached and quoted.
- How many you won.
- Total spend.
- Profit on the jobs you won.
Then look at where the money goes. If some job types convert well and others do not, change what you accept.
Making your Thumbtack jobs work harder
Each job you win from Thumbtack can build something you keep:
- Ask for a Google review at the end of the job, using a direct link. The free review link generator makes one.
- Photograph the finished work and post it on Facebook and Instagram.
- Track how many customers later call you direct or come back for more.
Review requests by text need the customer's mobile number and consent. This is general information, not legal advice.
If direct inquiries grow, you have room to lower your Thumbtack spend. There is more on that in the pillar guide. To compare platforms, see is Angi worth it for contractors and the paying for leads comparison page.
Plan: Building the part you keep
Mitch does not send you leads. Send in a finished job and it drafts the Facebook and Instagram post. On the Local plan ($189 a month) it also sends the Google review request 24 to 72 hours later and drafts replies to your Google reviews. Nothing posts until you approve it. 14-day free trial, no card, month to month.
Keep the reviews you earn
14 days free, no card. Send in one finished job and see the posts Mitch writes from it.