Leads and what marketing costs

HomeAdvisor for contractors: what to check before you sign

HomeAdvisor reviews from contractors are mixed, and prices are not public. Here is what the official pro pages say, how to read reviews fairly and how to test it yourself.

Search for "HomeAdvisor reviews" and you will find strong opinions in both directions. Some contractors say it fills their diary. Others say it cost them more than it earned. Both can be true, because the result depends on your trade, your area, how fast you reply and how many of your quotes you win.

This post does not repeat anyone's story as fact. It covers what HomeAdvisor's own pro pages say, how to read reviews fairly and how to test the service with your own numbers. It is part of our guide to paying for leads vs owning your reputation.

HomeAdvisor and Angi

The pro help pages on HomeAdvisor's domain are titled "Angi Leads Pro" and describe the Angi Leads service. If you are comparing HomeAdvisor and Angi as two options, ask the rep to explain exactly what you would be buying, under which name, with which terms. Our post on Angi covers the same service from the Angi side.

What the pro FAQ says

We read the official pro FAQ for this post. Here is what it states.

  • You pay "a nominal fee for each lead you match to," and different sized jobs have different lead fees. No amounts are given, and it points you to a phone line.
  • Customers are connected with multiple service professionals. A request can reach several pros.
  • You choose the type of work you do and the area you serve.
  • You can turn the service on or off in your profile, and schedule it to switch back on later.
  • The company makes no guarantee of work volume.

The page also describes a separate card payment tool for invoices, which charges a processing fee per transaction. That is a different thing from lead fees, so do not mix the two up when you read pricing talk.

One thing in that FAQ is confusing. A line in the cost section says there are no back-end win fees or per-lead charges, which seems to refer to a different service listed on the page and not the leads product. If you see that line quoted somewhere, ask the rep what it applies to.

Everything else, such as contract length, renewal, credits for bad leads and the real price for your area, is not public on the pages we read. Get it in writing.

How to read HomeAdvisor reviews from contractors

Reviews are useful when you read them for questions, not for verdicts.

What to look for:

  • Details you can test: trade, area, how many leads, how many won, what it cost.
  • The same issue raised by many people over time, such as billing or cancellation, which you can then ask the rep about directly.
  • Dates. Policies change, and an old complaint may no longer apply.

What to be careful with:

  • One dramatic story. It tells you what happened to one business.
  • Glowing posts that read like marketing.
  • Anyone quoting a specific price without saying the trade and zip code. Prices vary by both.

Reviews should shape the questions you ask and the terms you check. They should not make the decision for you.

Who it tends to suit

HomeAdvisor-style lead services tend to suit a contractor who:

  • Wants steady inbound requests and can respond within minutes.
  • Has job profits high enough to absorb the fee on every lead, won or lost.
  • Quotes well and keeps a good win rate.
  • Is willing to track results for a trial period before committing long term.

They tend to disappoint a contractor who runs thin margins, competes on quality, or cannot answer quickly while out on a job.

Questions to ask the sales rep

  1. What is the price per lead for my trade and zip code, and is there a monthly or annual membership as well?
  2. How long is the agreement, and how do renewal and cancellation work?
  3. How many other contractors receive the same lead?
  4. What happens with a bad lead: credit, refund or nothing?
  5. Can I cap monthly spend, pause matching and stop billing when I pause?
  6. Can I get all of this in writing?

How to test it

Run a 60 to 90 day trial with a spreadsheet. Log every lead: date, job type, whether you reached the customer, whether you quoted, whether you won, the fee and the profit.

Cost per job won = total lead spend / jobs won

Example, with made-up figures. Tom's Electric is an invented business and spends $450 in a month and wins 3 jobs, so each job cost $150 in lead fees. If a job nets Tom $1,100, he is probably happy. If a job nets $300, he has a problem. The same $150 means different things on different jobs.

Do not forget the hours. A lead you chase for three calls and a site visit and then lose has a cost even if the platform fee is small.

Turn each lead job into something you own

Every job from a lead service can also build your own reputation.

  • Ask for a Google review after the job, using a direct link. The free review link generator makes one.
  • Post photos of the finished work on Facebook and Instagram.
  • Add the customer to your repeat and referral list.

Review texts need the customer's mobile number and consent. This is general information, not legal advice.

When direct inquiries from Google, referrals and repeat customers grow, you have the option of cutting your lead spend. Wait until then. See the paying for leads comparison for a side-by-side, or read about Thumbtack and Nextdoor as other options.

Plan: Building the part you keep

Mitch does not send leads. You send in a finished job and it drafts the Facebook and Instagram post. On the Local plan ($189 a month) it also sends a Google review request 24 to 72 hours later and drafts replies to each Google review. Nothing posts until you approve. Plans start at $99 a month, with a 14-day free trial and no card.

Make each job count twice

14 days free, no card. Try Local on one finished job and get the posts and the review request together.

14 days free. No card. Cancel any time.

Sources

Checked October 9, 2026. Terms change, so confirm current details with the provider.

Questions answered

Is HomeAdvisor the same as Angi?
The HomeAdvisor-hosted pro help pages are titled Angi Leads Pro and describe the Angi Leads service. Ask the sales rep which product, terms and fees apply to you today.
How much does HomeAdvisor charge contractors?
The pro FAQ says you pay a fee for each lead you match to and that different sized jobs have different lead fees. It gives no amounts. Ask for pricing for your trade and zip code in writing.
Are HomeAdvisor leads exclusive?
The pro FAQ says customers are connected with multiple service professionals, so a request can reach more than one pro. Ask the rep how many contractors receive the leads you would get.
How should I read HomeAdvisor reviews from contractors?
Look for details that you can test against your own numbers, such as win rate and cost per job won, and treat single stories as one person's experience. Then run your own trial.

Try it on your next job.

Start the trial, take a photo when you finish tomorrow's job, and see what Mitch does with it.

14 days free. No card. Cancel any time.